Monthly Subscription
The Pawfood Critics Tasting Box
$49.99/month
Founding member pricing — locked in for life
What's in every box
5 surprise single-ingredient treat samples
Each a different protein — chosen for sensitive stomachs
Digital tasting scorecard to rate every treat
Personalized recommendations based on your ratings
Curated by dog nutrition experts
We don't reveal what's inside — that's the whole point. Every box is a curated mystery of all-natural, single-ingredient treats sourced from proteins most dogs have never tried. Your dog discovers what they love. You finally know what to buy.
Join the Founding Pack →The Experience
More than a treat box. A discovery.
Most dogs eat the same thing every day. Pawfood Critics is the first subscription built around finding out what your dog actually prefers — protein by protein, reaction by reaction.
The Mystery
You never know what proteins are coming. Neither does your dog. That's what makes it exciting.
The Scorecard
Loved It / Liked It / Meh / Hard Pass. Simple ratings that teach us everything.
The Learning
Every rating makes the next box smarter. Over time, your box becomes uniquely your dog's.
Ready to find out?
Join the founding pack. Cancel anytime.
Join the Founding Pack — $49.99/month →Free shipping. No commitment. Cancel anytime.