The Process
How Pawfood Critics works
Three simple steps. One very happy dog. A lifetime of knowing exactly what they love.
Take the quiz
Tell us your dog's size, breed, and any known allergies or sensitivities. It takes two minutes and helps us curate the safest, most exciting box for your dog.
Dog's size and weight
Known allergies or proteins to avoid
Any previous reactions to treats
Receive your surprise box
5 single-ingredient treat samples arrive at your door. Each is a different protein — chosen specifically for dogs with sensitive stomachs. The contents are always a surprise.
5 unique protein samples per box
All single-ingredient, all-natural
Curated for sensitive stomachs
New proteins every month — never repeated
Rate every treat
After your dog tries each treat, submit their reaction on the digital tasting scorecard. Loved It, Liked It, Meh, or Hard Pass. We use every rating to make the next box better.
Simple 4-option rating per treat
Ratings stored and analyzed
Next box personalized to your dog
Full-size recommendations for favorites
The Scorecard
Your dog's opinion, captured.
After each treat, rate your dog's reaction. Four options. No overthinking.
Ready to start the tasting?
Take the Quiz →Cancel anytime. Free shipping. No commitment.